Baseball: The Problem With Combined Stats

Ichiro Suzuki unintentionally created a debate when he reached his career milestone. Photo Credit: Arturo Pardavila III,

Major League Baseball has a new issue that no one could have foreseen: combined statistics.

We’re one week removed from Ichiro Suzuki getting his 3,000th hit as a member of the Miami Marlins. He currently has a total of 4,281 hits as both a Major Leaguer and from his career in Japan. That puts him at the top of the list combined, passing Pete Rose and Ty Cobb with the most hits.

Ichiro’s accomplishments caused debate, with Rose stating on FOX Sports that he’s not the true hit king of baseball. Rose said this after Ichiro passed Rose for the most career hits with his combined stats.

Unfortunately, the debate gets a little murkier than that.

Hideki Matsui
Hideki Matsui made a career in the majors. What happens when you combine his Major League stats with his time as a Yomirui Giant? Photo Credit: Keith Allison,

For example, let’s take a look at Hideki Matsui’s career stats. The outfielder played for the New York Yankees, Los Angeles Angles of Anaheim, Oakland A’s and the Tampa Bay Rays. He logged in 175 home runs during his major-league career.

However, Hideki Matsui was a monster with the Yomirui Giants. He hit 332 home runs with the club. That brings his career total to an impressive 507 dingers. Does that make Matsui a strong candidate for Cooperstown as well?

Let’s go further than the countrymen of Japan in Ichiro and Matsui. There are some baseball players that play past the end of the season. There are leagues in the Caribbean where Major Leaguers can take part on separate teams. Edwin Encarnacion, current designated hitter for the Toronto Blue Jays, took part in the Dominican Winter League in 2006-08, 2010 and 2011 for the Aguilas Cibaenas.

A teammate of his during the 2010 season was current Washington National second baseman Daniel Murphy, who is having a career season for the Nationals.

Neither man has the stats to warrant consideration to the Hall of Fame, yet. But what if they did What if someone playing in that league racked up the hits to contribute to a stellar MLB career?

And let’s not start on the minor leagues. It’s professional baseball, but there are plenty of players who have made a career as legends in the minors.

The bottom line is baseball has moved past the staple of “America’s Pastime”. It’s worthy to be called a global phenomenon.

Baseball went global before the inception of the World Baseball Classic. The inclusion of players from other countries can attest to that.

Should stats from other leagues factor into a player’s career? If yes, understand that everyone gets a boost. The great names that played in the majors get a boost from other pro leagues. In other words, maybe it would just balance out.

That’s not our conundrum to solve. That is up to the baseball purists and those in Cooperstown to make that decision.

Regardless, it would be pretty cool to see those stats mean more than just “numbers from other places”.

Remember to check out the Facebook page for the Update. You can also check out my professional website for my other works and accomplishments. Don’t forget to like me on Facebook, follow me on Twitter and keep on reading. Until then, watch sports you knuckleheads!

Yours Truly,

Sebastian Maldonado

Copyright @ 2007


One thought on “Baseball: The Problem With Combined Stats

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s